Thursday, 15 December 2011
I very much identify with your post, as well as with significant points
in other posts. It is a disease, because a disease is a biomedically
determined cluster of (again biomedically defined/approved) symptoms for
which a (biomedically designated) pathology or prognosis is
applied/expected. Being sick is different from feeling ill because we
can convince other people that we are in a deviant/abnormal/undesirable
temporary/permanent life state. Its important for managing
work/living/relationships that we can convince them - what is a sick day
vs a holiday if we cant for example? Disease is a life state with
specific conditions attached (cluster of symptoms, prognosis etc) that
means we can convince powerful medical professionals (and lots of other
folks and ourselves!) that what we experience is real, is less
temporary than sick and (usually) not under our own control. Each type
of state - ill, sick or diseased comes along with important consequences
for our self-esteem, thoughts and feelings and for the way others treat
us, as well as for our pockets and life choices. What
we subjectively/emotionally/bodily experience is only a part of the
'illness' or sickness or disease. Depression may be a highly reasonable
reaction to an uninspiring and unhealthy life position, or it may be a
baffling result of a tormented consciousness, a temporary, permanent
or transient experience of misery. Managing physical symptoms such as
pain can also follow this pattern. If an asprin doesn't cure all pains,
anti-depressants wont soothe all minds. Nor does any other treatment
work for any condition in isolation. Sometimes asking people what they
need is best, sometimes its worst. Sometimes people need to talk,
sometimes they need to exercise and move into new circumstances to get
better, sometimes the pain is such that they don't have the faith in a
different ending anymore. But putting people into boxes will fail most
people, especially if they, as people and as a group, haven't designed
the box themselves.
Saturday, 3 December 2011
Wednesday, 14 September 2011
Thursday, 8 September 2011
Wednesday, 17 August 2011
Saturday, 23 July 2011
Wednesday, 20 July 2011
Saturday, 11 June 2011
Friday, 10 June 2011
Thursday, 9 June 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





